09.26.08

I think that I shall never see

Posted in American vs. British, grammar at 6:39 am by Bill Brohaugh

I shall be brief. Or will be brief. Or something. I share the usage confusion of the Motivated Grammar blog, in the recent post “In which I realize I’ll never use ’shall’ as an Englishman would”:

I [use the word] intermittently, and I have a fairly clear idea in my head of a few instances when one ought to use shall:

(1) We shall overcome.
(2) Shall we dance?
(3) You Shall Know Our Velocity!

Okay, that’s about it.

I shan’t look for more examples, either. But in case the precise use of will and shall confuses you, consider this 1900 visual guide presented by Motivated Grammar:

shilly-shally

To me, this kind of looks like a Buck Rogers decoder ring, or a map of Dante’s Nine Circles of Hell. Check out the example in the upper left: “Because what must be will be” (the future’s not ours to see! Que sera, sera, which I believe to be the official elevator music between at least two Circles of Hell).

2 Comments »

  1. SoupAddict Karen said,

    September 26, 2008 at 8:48 am

    One of the inner circles commands me, “Thou Wilt.” Being the end of week, and that I barely dragged myself into my own circlet of hell cubelet, thank you, I believe I shall wilt….

  2. JohnnyB said,

    September 26, 2008 at 12:12 pm

    Yes I noticed the “Because what must be will be” in the upper left - explaining when to use “shall”

Leave a Comment